Blog #33 What You Probably Didn’t Know About the Singapore Stock Market

Let’s be honest. Most investors think they can predict the future. Else, how do you explain the fact that most people hold fewer than ten stocks in their portfolio?  The standard reply that it’s expensive to buy a diversified portfolio doesn’t cut – there is such a thing as exchange traded funds! On the SGX for example, there is the SPDR Straits Times Index ETF and the Nikko AM Straits Times Index ETF, both of which track the 30-stock Straits Times Index very closely and with low expense ratios to boot.  Indeed, why stop at Singapore, a tiny red dot in a big big world? Why miss out on the business opportunities presented by hundreds of firms spread across the continents?

The real answer to these “whys” is that investors simply don’t like diversifying broadly. What they want is bet on a few stocks in the hope that these stock pircks will turn out to be “jackpots”. Unknowingly, they fall into a behavioral trap called the overconfidence bias, an exaggerated belief in your skills to pick winners. A related bias is the “home bias”, which is the tendency to concentrate all your investments in one country like  Singapore if you are a resident of Singapore, Japanese, if you are a resident of Japan, the US if you are an American resident and so on.

To my Singapore readers, let me share with you the facts based on a long record of stock market returns from 1970 to 2017, a period of 48 years. The underlying data are monthly MSCI stock index returns for 17 countries comprising Singapore and 16 other developed markets (please refer to Blog #31 for a list of these countries).  I construct a world portfolio by giving each of the 16 foreign markets equal weight. All returns are in Singapore dollars.

I will summarize this large data set by showing three things: (a) the average returns of the world portfolio when the Singapore stock market experienced the worst 10% and 20% returns over the whole sample period, (b) the average returns of the world portfolio when the Singapore stock market experienced the best 10% and 20% of returns over the sample period and (c) the average return for Singapore and the world excluding Singapore’s best 10% returns (because these extreme returns are rare). I report all averages as annual numbers (i.e., 12 times the monthly average).

Here are the results.

CVAR

The first panel of the table shows average returns in the worst 10% and 20% of months in the Singapore stock market (SG). This “worst average” is called the 10% and 20% conditional value-at-risk or CVAR. You see that the world portfolio suffered a smaller average loss than SG when  the local market was “in the toilet”. For example, while SG suffered an average annual loss of 15% in the worst 10% of the sample, the world portfolio was down by only 4%. In other words, SG under-performed the world portfolio by 8% during these periods (last column). A similar result holds for the worst 20% of months for SG.

The middle panel shows the flip side of the above results. Here, I present the conditional value-at-gain (a term I invented). What this panel says is that when SG is doing very well, the world does well too, though not to the same extent.  So, in these jolly periods, SG outperformed the world portfolio. Consider this as the price you pay for protection from diversification.

The last panel throws out the best 10% of SG returns to see what happens in less exuberant periods. The results are surprising.  First, the average return for SG is now close to zero (the actual average is negative 0.19% per year which is close to zero). Hence, if you miss just 30 of the best months in Singapore, you earned almost nothing for your effort. I don’t know about you, but I sure don’t want to stake all my money in a market where the growth of my retirement money depends on just a handful of over-the-top returns.

How about the world portfolio? The same panel shows that even when we exclude the best 10% SG returns, the average return of the world portfolio is still positive and indeed, a highly respectable 8% a year.  While this is about 2.4% lower than the full sample world average, it is clear that the world portfolio is only marginally affected by the (irrational?) exuberance of the Singapore stock market. This stability is the precious gift of global diversification.

 

 

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Blog #33 What You Probably Didn’t Know About the Singapore Stock Market

  1. Thank you for writing this. I’ve always wondered why my peers keep buying in the STI, like it’s the only stock market in the world to invest in. Personally I don’t have a single holding in STI but with S&P500, developed europe and emerging markets ETF. But buying into another ETF that represents the world or the US / Europe / EM are usually in USD which exposes us to FX risk, which if the investment is used in the long-run for retirement (decades ahead), doesn’t seem sound at all. Unlike stocks, FX doesn’t “appreciate” over time, it doesn’t pay dividends and it’s all relative. That’s why I’m not so sure what I should hold in my portfolio mix till now. A lot of books are American-based, but we don’t have funds in SGD (nor the liquidity in SGX), so there’s always this friction. What are your thoughts on this?

    Like

    1. Yes, Singaporeans also think the SGD is the king of currencies. While the SGD has indeed outperformed the USD ar least since the 1970s, my historical redults already factored this fx depreciation of the USD and it shows that the world portfolio superior to SGX on a risk adjusted basis (ie., in terms of the Sharpe ratio). So if history repeats, diversification will still be beneficial. That said, the usual disclaimer applies. Thank you for your interest in this topic.

      Like

  2. SGD is strong and worthy of investing in. But I would’t put all my money in it.

    USD against SGD has been declining from 1.7 in the old days til 1.3 nowadays. We can expect the trend to go on. Especially with more money printing and higher debts incurred by the US govt, who knows when it will bottom out?

    On the other hand, Investors in the US have been pouring money in the stocks til they have become so overvalued now. As a result I am cautiously putting my money in only at appropriate times, e.g. corrections. Still waiting for a big crash .. that’s only when we know the worst has come ..

    Anyway do you know why certain SG stock such as Capitaland, Sembcorp, Ho bee land have some sort of cyclical pattern? It’s the business cycles? Stock like ST Eng also show a crude sine wave pattern on a downward trend and rebounding recently. Do you think these are tradable?

    Like

    1. Well, the prices of some stocks can exhibit some sort of cyclical pattern simply because of the industry there are in. A good example of a cyclical industry is semiconductors (technology driven cycles) and oil and gas (demand for which is correlated with economic growth). I have personally not studied whether it is profitable to predict such cycles.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s